Home // What We're Reading // Editorial: A new year to get school reform right?

Editorial: A new year to get school reform right?

Editorial: A new year to get school reform right?
Wednesday, Jan 2, 2019

group of school kids raising hands in classroom

The Detroit News

Published 10:00 p.m. ET Jan. 1, 2019

Gov. Rick Snyder signed a bill Friday that will give Michigan’s schools A-F letter grades, a change that’s intended to offer parents a clear idea of how their child’s school is doing. The bill also erases the state law that requires a school reform officer.

Does that matter?

The fact no one is really talking about this fairly major change speaks volumes. The decade-old law had tasked the state Department of Education with hiring someone to oversee the state’s lowest-performing schools and implement turnaround plans.

The School Reform Office was supposed to ensure struggling schools followed improvement measures and enforce accountability, but its lack of effectiveness is why Snyder tried to bypass the office during his two terms in office.

Early in his tenure, Snyder created the now disbanded Education Achievement Authority, which sought to overhaul the 15 worst schools in Detroit.

And in 2015, Snyder made the bold move to shift the School Reform Office to the Department of Technology, Management and Budget from the Education Department so that he could have more direct oversight over the office. Michigan is one of only a few states to allow its governor so little control over schools, given the setup of the State Board of Education.

Even that move reaped little results. In early 2017, the SRO had threatened to close the worst-performing schools around the state — most of which were in Detroit. Yet the plan was poorly executed, and in the end nothing happened.

At that point, Snyder pretty much gave up. He worked with late state Superintendent Brian Whiston to fashion “partnership agreements” with low-performing districts. That model is still in place, and the MDE has created a new office to oversee those partnerships.

In mid-2017, Snyder moved the School Reform Office back under the direction of the MDE, given his confidence in Whiston, and the reality his plans for the SRO had failed. The MDE has since morphed the reform office into the partnership operation.

Whiston died last spring, and interim Superintendent Sheila Alles has remained committed to the partnerships. In November, she appointed William Pearson to serve as the latest school reform officer, in addition to directing the Office of Partnership Districts, which has its own line item of $3.5 million in the state budget.

MDE spokesman Martin Ackley says that Pearson will stay on in his role with the partnership office, even when the new law takes effect.

This complicated history is a reflection of the school reform law’s ultimate failure. At least erasing the current model gives lawmakers a fresh start to re-work the framework, if they choose to tackle it.

The A-F grading model will be a good foundation, but the state still needs a thoughtful system that offers true accountability.

Recent News


One More Item On Our 2018 To-Do List

Dec 12, 2018

Leading What’s Next… As we come to the end of another calendar year, it’s great to reflect on all that has been accomplished. We’ve made new strides in connecting business with...

Read More

BLM releases 2018 statewide economic benchmarking data

Nov 12, 2018

DETROIT, Mich.—Business Leaders for Michigan (BLM), the state’s business roundtable, released a major report on the state’s economic performance Monday, highlighting the impact of key policy and...

Read More

Business Leaders for Michigan Economic Forecast: MI Expected to Continue Growing Slower than Nation

Feb 7, 2020

LANSING—Michigan’s largest employers anticipate the state’s economic growth will continue to lag that of the U.S., though they are generally more optimistic about both the state and national eco...

Read More

Business Leaders for Michigan releases data-based strategic plan, offering solutions for Michigan’s toughest problems

Feb 3, 2020

Independent data on 50+ indicators of Michigan’s success compared to other states now available   LANSING, Mich. – Executive leadership from Michigan’s largest universities and companies ga...

Read More
What We're Reading

Michigan roads: how bad are they, how are they funded, and how on Earth can they be fixed?

Jan 30, 2020

From Michigan Radio: It is a fact universally acknowledged that Michigan has terrible roads. While there are a lot of arguments to be had about how to actually fix the roads by politicians and policy ...

Read More